In the 2000s, GTA was the target of several lawsuits in the United States. Victims' families accused the game of having influenced the perpetrators of crimes. Here is what became of these cases, stated factually.
The Buckner case (2003)
In October 2003, families of victims of a shooting in Tennessee demand 246 million dollars from Take-Two, Rockstar, Sony and Walmart. The two young shooters claimed to have been inspired by GTA III. The plaintiffs drop the case a few days later.
The Devin Moore case (2005)
In June 2003, in Alabama, a teenager kills three people, including two police officers. He was described as an avid GTA player. The families file a lawsuit in February 2005. The lawsuit is dismissed on 29 March 2006.
The Posey case (2006)
In September 2006, a lawsuit demanding 600 million dollars is filed in New Mexico against Sony, Take-Two and Rockstar, following a family tragedy in 2004. It is dismissed in December 2007.
Jack Thompson, the anti-GTA lawyer
Several of these proceedings are brought by Jack Thompson, a Florida lawyer who was very active against violent video games. He also opposes Bully in 2006: a judge examines the game and rejects his request for a ban.
In March 2007, Take-Two sues him to stop him from blocking the sale of GTA IV and Manhunt 2. The case ends in a settlement.
For its part, the Florida bar begins disciplinary proceedings against the lawyer, for matters related to his professional conduct. On 25 September 2008, the Florida Supreme Court orders his permanent disbarment.
What these cases show
None of these lawsuits led to a conviction of Rockstar or Take-Two. They do illustrate the debate of the time on the influence of violent video games, which was very heated just as GTA was becoming a social phenomenon.