“Hot Coffee” is the most famous controversy in GTA history. It hit San Andreas in 2005. Here are the facts, in order, as they were reported.
A scene cut, but left in the code
During development, Rockstar plans a sexual mini-game. It is eventually made inaccessible so that the game can get the “Mature” rating (17 and over) in the United States. But the content remains in the game's files.
The discovery by a modder (June 2005)
On 9 June 2005, a Dutch modder, Patrick Wildenborg, publishes a patch that reactivates the scene on PC. He names it “Hot Coffee”. Modders had also found the code in the PS2 version.
The game re-rated “Adults Only”
On 20 July 2005, the American rating body, the ESRB, moves all editions of the game from “Mature” to “Adults Only”, restricted to adults. Several major retailers, including Walmart, Target and Best Buy, then stop selling it.
In Australia, the classification body revokes the game's rating on 29 July 2005, which amounts to banning its sale.
Rockstar's response
- 11 August 2005: a patch disables Hot Coffee on PC.
- September 2005: a modified version, rated “Mature” again, is released on PC and Xbox.
- November 2005: a “Special Edition” without the mini-game arrives on PS2.
The political reaction
Senator Hillary Clinton asks the US competition authority (FTC) to open an investigation. At the end of 2005 she introduces a bill on the sale of violent or explicit games to minors. The bill is never passed.
The legal aftermath
- June 2006: settlement with the FTC. Take-Two and Rockstar commit to providing better information about the content of their games. No fine is imposed for Hot Coffee.
- January 2008: a consumer class action ends in a settlement. Fewer than 3,000 buyers claim compensation.
- September 2009: a shareholder lawsuit is concluded with a settlement of more than 20 million dollars.
What remains
The affair showed that content that is inaccessible but present in a game could count toward its rating.