EN
← All guides
The real Florida

Key lime pie, Florida's official pie

Published · 1 min read ·

In the Florida Keys, you can't escape key lime pie. This lime tart has become a symbol of Florida. A short history of a very local dessert.

What's in it?

It is served plain, with meringue or with whipped cream. The filling is pale yellow: ripe key limes are yellow.

Why condensed milk?

Before modern refrigeration, fresh milk was scarce in the Keys. Condensed milk, which keeps for a long time, took over. The recipe, incidentally, closely resembles a lime pie published by the Borden brand in 1931 in an advertising booklet.

A debated origin

Legend speaks of a Key West cook, “Aunt Sally.” No evidence confirms it. The pie is well documented in the Keys from the 1930s on. Before that, solid sources are lacking.

Limes from elsewhere

Paradoxically, key limes have not been grown commercially in the United States since the 1926 Miami hurricane. The fruit used today is often imported.

An official pie

In 2006, a Florida law makes key lime pie the official state pie. Not to be confused with the official dessert, which is strawberry shortcake.

The link with the game

Rockstar has said nothing about the cuisine of the Leonida Keys. But if you want a Keys atmosphere in your living room on release night, this pie is an obvious choice.

A law that never came to be

In 1965, a bill already sought to penalize those who sold under this name a pie made without real key limes. It did not pass. It would take until 2006 for the pie to receive official recognition.

💡 A real key lime pie is not green. If it is, it's often food coloring.
Sources

Spotted a mistake in this guide? Let us know.